James Nicoll Reviews

Home > Reviews

Reviews

Ashes, Ashes

To The Warm Horizon

By Choi Jin-Young (Translated by Soje)

10 Dec, 2025

Translation

0 comments

Choi Jin-Young’s 2021 To the Warm Horizon is a dystopian apocalypse novel. Soje’s English translation also came out in 2021.

Coping with our ordinary civilization can be both challenging and tedious: looking for jobs and housing, searching for relationships, raising children with unreliable social support. The great pandemic freed the masses from all that!

For most folks, it ushered them through the gate of death.

Read more ➤

This Is Magical

A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping

By Sangu Mandanna 

9 Dec, 2025

Miscellaneous Reviews

1 comment

Sangu Mandanna’s 2025 A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping is a stand-alone contemporary fantasy.

Sera Swan is a powerful British mage, the most powerful since the legendary Albert Grey. Having cast at age ten a spell that most adult witches could not cast, she was inducted into the Guild — not entirely or really, even a little voluntarily — and placed under the mentorship of the aforesaid Albert Gray.

In the eyes of most Guild members, Sera committed the egregious sin of being born to a foreign (Icelandic) mother and a very foreign (Indian) father. In the eyes of Albert Gray, Sera committed the far more serious faux pas of potentially rivalling him. However, Sera’s gift is too valuable for the Guild to squander.

Squandering her gift is Sera’s job. Which gets us to the dead woman in the garden.

Read more ➤

All of These Voices

A Mouthful of Dust  (Singing Hills, volume 6)

By Nghi Vo 

4 Dec, 2025

Miscellaneous Reviews

5 comments

2025’s A Mouthful of Dust is the sixth volume in Nghi Vo’s Singing Hills secondary-universe fantasy series.

Cleric Chih of Singing Hills and their hoopoe companion Almost Brilliant traverse the Singing Hills in search of stories. These are carefully recorded and preserved for the edification of those to come.

Even the unpleasant stories, such as those from Baolin’s great famine.

Read more ➤

Help of the Helpless

Bambi  (Bambi, volume 1)

By Felix Salten (Translated by Jack Zipes)

3 Dec, 2025

Translation

7 comments

Felix Salten’s 1928 Bambi, a Life in the Woods (German: Bambi: Eine Lebensgeschichte aus dem Walde) is a coming-of-age novel. The Jack Zipes English translation came out in 2022. Illustrations are by Alenka Sottler.

Bambi’s life is full of wonders… because Bambi is a newborn fawn and the full horror of woodland existence has yet to be made clear to him.

Read more ➤

In Tempestuous Seasons

Chanur’s Venture  (Chanur, volume 2)

By C J Cherryh 

2 Dec, 2025

Meetpoint

4 comments

1984’s Chanur’s Venture is the second volume in C. J. Cherryh’s Chanur science fiction series. Venture is also the first volume in the trilogy made up of the second, third, and fourth books in the five-book series. More on that later.

Having successfully resolved the matter of the human Tully, now living on The Pride of Chanur, Pyanfar Chanur is free to continue her unremarkable and entirely trouble-free life as the captain of the interstellar trading vessel, Pride. Or she would be, except for all the cascading effects of the earlier conflict.

Read more ➤

Daylight At Last

The Incredible Umbrella  (Incredible Umbrella, volume 1)

By Marvin Kaye 

30 Nov, 2025

Because My Tears Are Delicious To You

8 comments

1979’s secondary universe comedic fantasy fix-up The Incredible Umbrella is the first volume in Marvin Kaye’s Incredible Umbrella tetralogy.

James Adrian Fillmore traveled for research. The trip was a failure, as the records on which he hoped to base his dissertation were denied to him. Worse yet, he returned to his small American college to discover that he had lost his thesis advisor to promotion, leaving Fillmore with two unpromising potential replacements.

One solution would be to arrive at some brilliant new thesis with which to impress his superiors. Fillmore makes a good effort at that. Another solution would be to purchase an enchanted umbrella that would sweep him off to another universe. In this second alternative, Fillmore enjoys total (but unexpected) success.

Read more ➤